Digital Asset
Intelligence
Theme

Search 3CBlock

News, exchanges, regulatory intelligence, reviews and Voices.

Judge Acquits ‘MEV Brothers’ of Wire Fraud in $25M Ethereum Exploit

Add us on Google

Summary: A federal judge ruled that Anton and James Peraire-Bueno did not make material misrepresentations during a 2023 MEV exploit, acquitting them of wire fraud and money laundering charges after a previous mistrial.

Credibility editorial illustration by 3CBlock
Illustration: 3CBlock

Acquittal on Federal Charges

Anton and James Peraire-Bueno have been acquitted of wire fraud and money laundering charges related to a $25 million Ethereum exploit executed in April 2023. Judge Jessica Clarke ruled on Monday that the prosecution failed to meet the legal burden for conviction, stating that “the government failed to prove that the Peraire-Buenos made any material misrepresentations in the execution of their scheme.”

The acquittal follows a weeks-long trial in November that ended in a deadlocked jury and was declared a mistrial. The brothers had faced federal indictment in May 2024 on charges prosecutors described as a “first-of-its kind wire fraud and money laundering scheme,” which included conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit money laundering, and conspiracy to receive stolen property.

Judicial Reasoning and ‘Code Is Law’

In her opinion, Judge Clarke emphasized the specific nature of the Ethereum network. She concluded that Ethereum operates as a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use… without the safeguards that exist in regulated markets.” While acknowledging that the brothers’ actions “may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost’s ‘design,’” she determined that their conduct “made no misrepresentation in its execution that can form the basis for fraud.”

The ruling draws a parallel to the case of Avraham Eisenberg, whose 2022 exploitation of Mango Markets resulted in charges that were overturned last year using similar legal reasoning. Judge Clarke’s decision is limited to the sufficiency of evidence for the specific charges presented and does not address whether the brothers’ behavior was “right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes.”

The 2023 Exploit and Disclosure

The Peraire-Bueno brothers generated approximately $25 million in just 12 seconds by exploiting a design flaw in Flashbots’ MEV-boost relay. The incident involved a bait-and-switch tactic targeting MEV trading bots. Shortly after the exploit, the pair disclosed a separate vulnerability under the moniker “Low Carb Crusader,” providing details on a block equivocation strategy to mitigate future risks.

Industry Reaction

Crypto legal experts have praised the verdict for rejecting the prosecution’s “honest validator” theory. Peter Van Valkenburgh of Coin Center had previously warned that such a theory could allow the government to “impose its own code of conduct on Ethereum validators.”

Following the ruling, Anton Peraire-Bueno, known online as “Curious Rabbit,” thanked family and friends who had “rearranged their lives around this case” since the indictment. He stated, “in the end, it’s a good story when the good guys win.” His brother James echoed these sentiments, indicating plans for a celebratory beer.