Digital Asset
Intelligence
Theme

Search 3CBlock

News, exchanges, regulatory intelligence, reviews and Voices.

Hyperliquid Policy Center Backs CFTC Rules Separating Prediction Markets From Gambling

Add us on Google

Summary: The Hyperliquid Policy Center filed comment letters supporting two Commodity Futures Trading Commission measures introduced on October 19 that distinguish federally regulated event contracts from state-licensed gambling products, urging regulators to finalize the rules without textual changes.

Compliance editorial illustration by 3CBlock
Illustration: 3CBlock

HPC Supports Dual CFTC Measures

The Hyperliquid Policy Center (HPC) has formally filed comment letters supporting two distinct rules issued by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that aim to separate prediction market contracts from gambling products. The organization argues that despite referencing similar underlying events, the trading structures of these products require separate regulatory treatment under federal law. This submission comes as the agency seeks to clarify the jurisdictional boundaries between derivatives markets and state-regulated gaming activities.

On October 19, the CFTC introduced two measures designed to clarify how event contracts and gambling products fall under different legal frameworks. The first rule, which has already taken effect, excludes certain state-licensed and Tribal gaming products from the federal definition of swaps first rule. This exclusion ensures that traditional gaming activities regulated at the state or Tribal level do not inadvertently trigger federal derivatives oversight. Meanwhile, the second proposal would clarify that qualifying event contracts traded on registered exchanges fall within the scope of federal derivatives regulation second proposal. HPC supports both measures, maintaining that the operational differences between exchanges and gambling operators justify this bifurcated approach.

Structural Differences in Trading Arrangements

In its commentary, HPC emphasized that exchanges and gambling operators expose customers to fundamentally different trading arrangements. The organization explained that gambling operators generally determine prices and take positions directly against their customers, creating a principal-to-customer relationship. In contrast, registered exchanges function as neutral venues that match up competing orders from various participants. These exchanges charge transaction fees regardless of which side wins the order, rather than profiting from customer losses. This structural distinction forms the basis of HPC’s argument that prediction markets operating on registered exchanges should be treated as derivatives rather than gambling.

The policy center warned that applying state gambling regulations to derivatives based solely on their contract references could create significant legal uncertainty. HPC provided examples of other financial products that could be impacted by such interpretations, including agricultural contracts, energy contracts, currency contracts, and interest rate contracts. If state laws were allowed to override federal classifications based on the subject matter of the contract, it could disrupt the regulatory consistency of broader derivatives markets.

Legal Disputes and Jurisdictional Clarity

The CFTC’s efforts to define the scope of its authority over prediction markets have faced resistance. A number of states have objected to the federal approach, arguing that some of these products run afoul of current state gambling laws. However, federal courts have reached conflicting decisions concerning whether these contracts fall under federal derivatives law or state gambling statutes. This judicial inconsistency has created a complex landscape for operators seeking to comply with both federal and state requirements.

HPC urged regulators to make it clear that state classifications should not take precedence over federal regulation of registered exchanges. The group requested clarification that applicable gambling laws refer specifically to the jurisdiction licensing the operator, rather than imposing extraterritorial restrictions on federally regulated entities. By establishing this hierarchy, HPC argues that the CFTC can provide a stable regulatory environment for innovation while respecting the authority of states and Tribal governments over traditional gambling activities within their borders.

Specific Recommendations for Final Rules

In its comment letters, HPC outlined six specific changes or clarifications it believes are necessary for the final rules. The organization urged the CFTC to finalize the gambling exclusion without changing its regulatory text, preserving the clarity of the current proposal. Additional recommendations involve establishing the specific characteristics that define gambling products and connecting the two rules with explicit references in the regulation. HPC also suggested that language under the Commodity Exchange Act be used to define event contracts, ensuring that the statutory basis for regulation is clear and consistent.

The push for regulatory clarity occurs alongside broader developments in digital asset oversight. Separately, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has outlined proposed changes to crypto broker-dealer regulations, covering capital requirements and customer protections the SEC has outlined proposed changes to crypto broker-dealer regulations. While the SEC focuses on broker-dealer obligations, the CFTC’s actions represent a critical step in defining the market structure for event-based derivatives. HPC’s support for the CFTC’s approach highlights the industry’s preference for a federal framework that distinguishes between speculative trading on neutral exchanges and traditional wagering against house-backed operators.